Directory:The Wikipedia Point of View/Peter Damian Evidence

Evidence for the Arbitration Committee

The Arbitration Committee (September 2008)

• FayssalF szvestgmail.com
• FloNight
• FT2 ft2wikipedia.inboxgmail.com
• Jdforrester jdforrestergmail.com
• Jpgordon user.jpgordongmail.com
• Kirill_Lokshin kirill.lokshingmail.com
• Morven morvengmail.com
• Newyorkbrad Newyorkbradgmail.com
• Sam_Blacketer sam.blacketergmail.com
• Thebainer stephen.baingmail.com
• YellowMonkey

Peter Damian Background

Mathematics, logic and set theory

• Zermelo set theory Viewed 662 times in February 2008.
• Skolem's paradox
• Hume's_principle Viewed 1012 times in February 2008.
• Definitions of Logic
• Logical form Viewed 450 times in February 2008.

Philosophy and Logic

• Philosophy (viewed 138105 times in February 2008)
• Epistemic theory of miracles
• Concept and object
• Unity of the proposition
• Proper name
• Existence (since rather spoilt) - viewed 13994 times in February 2008.
• Russell's_paradox (since rather spoilt)
• Connotation and denotation (now considerably spoilt)
• Sense and reference
• Empty name
• Philosophical logic
• Plural quantification viewed Plural quantification times in February 2008.
• Ontological commitment
• Definition viewed 139877 times in February 2008.
• Singular term
• Ontological argument
• Definition

Medieval philosophy and logic

• Square of opposition
• Medieval philosophy Viewed 6460 times in February 2008
• Term logic (since much tampered with)
• Continuity thesis
• Ockham's Summa Logicae
• Scholasticism
• Isagoge Views
• Formal distinction new article.
• Second scholasticism new article.

Aristotle

• Aristotle's Metaphysics
• Aristotle's Posterior Analytics
• Aristotle's Categories
• Aristotle's On Interpretation

Biographies

• Duns Scotus Views
• Peter Damian (add some of his more idiosyncratic pronouncements)
• Henry of Ghent
• Jacopo Zabarella
• Walter Burley (just a stub right now)
• William of Ockham
• Peter Auriol
• William of Sherwood
• Ernst Schroder
• Peter Geach
• Crispin Wright
• Anthony Kenny
• Max Black (sadly the picture that Black's son sent me has been deleted)
• Simon of Faversham
• Jonathan Lowe
• Arthur Prior
• Paul Engelmann

Gospel music

• Mitchell's Christian Singers

Architecture

• Villa Cetinale
• Villa La Pietra
• Stonborough House

Argument

My argument for unblocking is very simple, as follows.

• (Major premiss) There is an important difference between principled and good-faith criticism of a contributor, and personal attack or harassment.
• (Minor premiss) My criticism of the editor called FT2 has been principled and in good faith. My actions should not therefore be labelled as 'harassment'.

The major premiss is clear. Everyone accepts that fair and principled criticism of another editor's action is essential to the continued survival of the Wikipedia project. To demonstrate the minor premiss, it will be necessary to discuss and criticise some of FT2's contributions to the Wikipedia project, and to see how the blocks of Peter Damian are connected with this.

Blocks of Peter Damian

Relevant accounts

• December block
• Peter Damian
• Hinnibilis (Doppelganger account)
• Renamed user 4 (renamed for personal reasons)

Block logs

• Damian blocks
• Renamed user 4 blocks

Relevant Blocks

• 4 December 2007 Radiant! (Smear campaign)
• 6 December 2007 WJBscribe (legal threat)
• 29 June 2008 Ryan Postlethwaite (Harassment)
• 13 August 2008 (MBisanz - personal attack or harassment)
• 01:45, 31 August 2008 by Coren (incivility)
• 23:11, 6 September 2008 by Jimbo Wales (harassment)

6 December 2007

WJBscribe (legal threat)

29 June 2008

Ryan Postlethwaite (Harassment)

13 August 2008

(MBiszanz - personal attack or harassment)

31 August 2008

by Coren (incivility)

6 September 2008

• by Jimbo Wales (harassment)